Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
American Public Transportation Association

 Evaluation Criteria for Rail Security Awards

Please submit all emergency management, emergency preparedness, and "all-hazards" programs and practices under the "Security" category for your mode.

Security Program/Project Effectiveness - 30 percent

The organization should be able to demonstrate a high level of resource allocation and management participation in the development and implementation of security initiatives.

When considering whether or not your program should be entered, ask yourself

  • “Does the program/project have a clear focus with specific intended results?” The organization should also be able to demonstrate solid and progressive results tied to overall agency goals and objectives.
  • “Is there before/after data that will support the efficacy of the program/project?” At a minimum, each organization must submit relevant data for the previous three years to demonstrate how the program or practice has effectively influenced the achievement of goals and objectives.
  • “Can the program/project be reasonably assumed to have led to the improvements?”
  • “Does data support that reductions are being sustained?” Data must be clearly defined and all data submitted must be validated and approved in writing by the organization’s chief executive officer (president, general manager). [See "notes" in the Nomination Procedures.]

Other types of data to document system security improvements as a result of the program/project might include:

  • Statistics on claims paid indicating the economic benefit of security improvements
  • Data reflecting reduction in major or minor crimes related to a specific initiative
  • Trend data on public comments or security surveys related to customer security

Security Program/Project Benefit Level – 35 percent

Organizations should submit evaluations of security or emergency management projects, programs, and initiatives that reflect the benefits the organization has derived from the program or practice. Organizations should be able to demonstrate gains or efficiencies in a variety of formats by being able to address some of the following questions:

  • What net financial benefits were accrued through implementation of this program/project?
  • How do direct savings compare to the program/project costs?
  • What indirect or non-financial benefits were achieved?
  • Did the program/project address a significant issue facing the agency?

Security Program/Project Innovation – 20 percent

Rail transportation is a dynamic environment that is constantly changing and challenging organizations to adapt to new situations. This is especially true in rail system security and emergency preparedness. 

Organizations should submit descriptions of innovative efforts having a positive effect on the operating environment and the safety of employees, passengers and the general public inhabiting that environment. Your submittal should illustrate the following:

  • How does this program/project differ from traditional approaches to the problem?
  • Does the program/project enhance common practices?
  • Does the program/project reflect a totally new or unusual approach?
  • How do the unique or innovative attributes of this project/program contribute to the effectiveness/ benefits achieved?

Security Program/Project Transferability – 15 percent

To truly be considered an Industry Leading Effective Practice, other transit providers must be able to adapt the program and implement it with similar results. Programs and practices must be described in such a way that other operators benefit from the success that you have had. Measures viewed as promising can then be implemented within other systems, and in doing so, the entire industry is improved over time. Organizations should submit descriptions of initiatives they developed that can address the following:

  • Does this program/project address a security issue that is of significance to many agencies?
  • Can the program/project be reasonably incorporated by other agencies?
  • Is the program/project likely to be more attractive than other existing approaches to the same types of security issues?

These questions and examples are provided only to invoke ideas. A single program could relate to multiple criteria.

Go back to the main Rail Safety & Security Excellence Awards page.

Copyright © 2018 American Public Transportation Association
1300 I Street NW
Suite 1200 East
Washington, DC 20005
Telephone (202) 496-4800 | Fax (202) 496-4324
Logo Usage | Privacy Policy | Staff Intranet